Garcia served a one-year suspension after testing positive for the banned substance Ostarine in 2024. His win over Devin Haney that year was later overturned by the New York State Athletic Commission.
He returned to the ring on May 2, 2025, when he fought Rolando “Rolly” Romero for the vacant WBA welterweight title. Garcia lost that fight. He has not fought since.
Despite the loss, Garcia was approved for a title fight against Barrios. He did not take a comeback bout, win an eliminator, or move into a mandatory position before being matched for the WBC belt.
That run of events has been what many critics keep pointing to. The view among those fans is that a fighter coming off a suspension and a title-fight loss would normally be expected to win again before getting another shot.
Garcia’s fans have defended the matchup, pointing to his popularity and past success. They argue that his profile makes the fight worth making, even without a recent win to push him back into contention.
From the WBC’s side, the bout is a voluntary defence for Barrios. Garcia is not the mandatory challenger, and no ordering process was required for the fight to be approved.
The date is set, and the fight is moving forward. What has not settled is the reaction to how Garcia arrived at another title opportunity, with debate continuing over whether the division’s usual merit system has been set aside.
